![](https://elreadingjournal.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/every-heart-a-doorway.jpg?w=683)
Prompts Filled: N/A
Tags: Nancy Whitman, Eleanor West, Sumi Onishi, Kade Bronson, Jaqueline “Jack” Wolcott, Jillian “Jill” Wolcott, Katherine Lundy, Fantasy, Urban Fantasy, Horror, Mystery, Murder Mystery, Novella, Young Adult, Boarding School, School, Alternate Universe, Magical Worlds, Magic, Missing Children, Runaways, Death, Murder, Dismemberment, Animal Death, Pet Death, Morbid, Macabre, Asexual, Asexuality, Asexual Character, Transgender, Trans Character, Transphobia, Trauma, Therapy, Outcasts, Misfits
Eleanor West’s Home for Wayward Children takes in children from the ages 10 to 19 who display a strange trauma after disappearing for various amounts of time. Miss West implores the desperate parents to leave their children in her care, and she educates them as in a normal school and offers therapy so that the children may recover and eventually return home.
Though “home” may be somewhere else entirely.
Nancy Whitman has just returned from the Halls of the Dead to her original world, to her dismay. She longs to return to the Underworld, and her parents don’t understand what happened to their daughter. So they send her to Eleanor West.
Nancy meets her new roommate, Sumi, and the other students who have also gone to different worlds and come back. Sumi went to a candy-and-rainbows world called “Confection.” Kade went to a land of fairies and goblins. Jack and Jill went to the Moors, a horror world of vampires and mad scientists. Nancy discovers that there are hidden doors to all sorts of worlds that only open to the right child, and that it is rare that a child who comes back ever finds that door again. But Nancy hopes. All the students hope.
Hope, Sumi says, is a bad word.
And then, only a few days after Nancy’s arrival, tragedy strikes: a student is found murdered. Nancy, having traveled to the Halls of the Dead, is a prime suspect, but she respects the dead, she doesn’t make them. With her new friends, Nancy must find the murderer, before their beloved school—a sanctuary from their parents, who don’t understand them, who can’t understand them—is closed for good.
Sparked Joy: 4/5 I loved the exploration of the aftermath of visiting another world. What happened to Alice after she returned from Wonderland? How did the Pevensie children cope after returning from Narnia?
Well, possibly with murder.
I think Eleanor actually does a really bad job helping the children under her care cope with coming back different and not being able to go back to the other worlds where they believe they belong. The therapy sessions that Lundy facilitates and everything that Eleanor and Lundy tell the children are… really unhelpful. Which is probably because Eleanor and Lundy also want to go back to their other worlds, but still. These people need real therapy.
I really liked this book, but Nancy’s ending made me knock it down from 5/5 to 4/5. Like I mentioned in my review of The Lady’s Guide to Petticoats and Piracy by Mackenzi Lee, I actually find the “ideal” character arc very satisfying: a character wants something, but in the end they get what they need. I feel like Nancy and the other children need to come to terms with what happened to them and what their life will be like going forward. But perhaps that’s not the story McGuire wanted to tell, and that’s okay. I still really liked this book.
Something I Learned: I suppose I learned that not every character needs to get what they need instead of what they want to make for a good story. Maybe Nancy’s arc was a tragedy, and that’s the point.
Something I’m Inspired to Do: I definitely want to read more of the Wayward Children series. I’m fascinated.
Every Heart a Doorway was published in 2016. Here is Seanan McGuire’s website. Support your local bookstore if you can, or visit your local library!